Submitted by Praphul on Sun, 2008-07-13 05:52.

“Jeevan Who Has No Religion” is the title of the controversial portion of the revised VIIth standard Social Science text book, now prescribed for study in the schools following the Kerala syllabus. Following is a verbatim translation of the little Malayalam story under the said title.

With the parents seated in the chairs in front of him, the headmaster began to fill up the application form for enrolling the new student:

“Son, what is your name?”

“Jeevan”

“Good … good name. Father's name?”

“Anwar Rasheed”

“Mother's name?”

“Lakshmi Devi”

The headmaster looked up and addressed the parents:

“Which is the religion you want to enter against the boy in the register”?

“Nothing. You may write no religion”

“Caste?”

“Not necessary”

The headmaster leaned back on his chair and asked a little reflectively:

“Supposing the child feels the need for a religion when he grows up?”

“Let him choose when he wants to”

Courtesy: http://pd.cpim.org/2008/0706_pd/07062008_9.htm
---------------------

Please post your opinion....

With LOVE,
Praphul O.

My opinion

#17159 On Sun, 2008 07 13 06:13 Praphul said,

Jai Gurudev
I feel it’s better to find a partner from same religion/cast because still our society is not matured enough to accept this. We need to wait for few more years….for such a divine world…
I personally feel we are part of this society...respect and love people irrespective of religion and cast. But for marriage try your best to find some one from your own religion or cast....otherwise its ok if you want to marry from other religion or cast...

Anyway I don’t feel anything wrong in this text book….Child must have the right to choose his own religion…

I would like to add this we should try to avoid such situation before marriage…

With LOVE,
Praphul O.

Jai Guru Dev

#17175 On Mon, 2008 07 14 14:36 navu said,

Jai Guru Dev

Let us give a point of origin to religion/cast free soceity.
We make people aware that we are all just humans.

navu

Jai gurudev

#17176 On Mon, 2008 07 14 14:58 Praphul said,

All our rituals are associated with religion... If all religion agree for a world with a cast/religion free world it’s possible…But I don’t think all religion accept this….Still we can see certain religion trying for mass conversion…They teach only they are right….So I think certainly its not the time to loose the identity of a particular religion…let us respect and love other religion and stay together…

I believe religious activities protect our tradition and make us a good human being no matter whatever religion we belong to….. I don’t think we need a religion free world.

With LOVE,
Praphul O.

Purpose of having a religion....Guruji's Answer

Q: What is the purpose of having a religion?

Sri Sri :You know from your birth to death, life is full of rituals. You are
born, you have a naming ceremony, you have a marriage ceremony, then
death ceremony.

All the important events in life are joined or
conjoined with the religion. So it has become a part of people's life.
Whats important today is to rise above and become spiritual. Religion
and rituals can divide but spirituality unites.

Courtesy: Deepa Nayak

Q: Is Religion important or human values more important?

#17202 On Thu, 2008 07 17 11:40 Praphul said,

Q: Is Religion important or human values more important?

Sri Sri: What do you think? Everybody must be having the same answer. Human values are very important at the same time religion has its own important place. In our country we do not respect our religion as done in other countries. We should respect our religion.

Courtesy: Deepa Nayak

Not just a matter of choice

#17160 On Sun, 2008 07 13 07:16 SureNell said,

Jai Gurudev Dearest Praphul

The entire text book issue has nothing to do with marriage, nothing to do with freedom of choice, nothing to do with society maturing...

The issue is much more deep-rooted and sinister. It is typical communist method of indoctrination. 21st Century avatar of Maculay. Nobody felt anything wrong with Maculay's presciption too, until it was too late.

Read and understand your earlier post thoroughly, read between lines. It has nothing to do with what you have innocently concluded :-) You will find everything is wrong with it if you scrutinize it with a bit more effort. In a subtle manner, they are painting everything in this society wrong and trying to prescribe their perceived right ways. This hurts the very social fabric of our nation. Exactly what Maculay succesfuly did to Indian education system a couple of centuries ago. Read the article by the minister in the link provided - (incidentally that portal happens to be the official party mouthpiece) The intention is very clear in the justification provided by the Minister :-)

As Gurudev said in one of the satsangs - Communalism, Corruption and Communism - 3 worst ills plaguing this country.

With lots of Love
Suresh

__________________________________________________________
The best vitamin to be a happy person is B1

Promoting an outdated concept...

#17162 On Sun, 2008 07 13 10:06 SureNell said,

Jai Gurudev

No...athesim is only pretence. They are promoting their own irrelevant and outdated concept and ideology. In fact this again is only a ruse to get themselves rich. Everyone knows that in these modern times, that ideology does not have a place.

For reasons very controversial I don't wish to elaborate here. But suffice to state - rest assured since every community is involved (sections that serve as their votebanks), they would definitely withdraw the same.

With lots of Love
Suresh

__________________________________________________________
The best vitamin to be a happy person is B1

Jai Gurudev

#17161 On Sun, 2008 07 13 08:12 Praphul said,

Dear Sureshetta,

Thank you for your reply. Do you think Govt’s intention is to promote atheism?

With LOVE,
Praphul O.